.
[Return
to List]
Eight Mindful Steps to Happiness
Session Six
Skillful Effort
-
Sitting Meditition - 20-30 minutes
-
Welcome and Introductions
-
There are three components of The Noble Eightfold Path: Virtue
(Skillful Speech, Skillful Action & Skillful Livelihood), Concentration
(Skillful Effort, Skillful Mindfulness & Skillful Concentration) &
Wisdom (Skillful Understanding & Skillful Thinking).
-
We began with Skillful Understanding - a conceptual understanding
of The Law of Cause and Effect and The Four Noble Truths.
-
Then we explored Skillful Thinking:
-
Importance of Intention
-
Each action (i.e., speech and deed) is preceded by a thought
-
Each unskillful thought is rooted in greed, hatred and delusion
-
Each skillful thought is rooted in non-greed (generosity),
non-hatred (loving-friendliness and compassion) and wisdom
-
We have experienced through Skillful Understanding and the
Law of Cause and Effect,
-
thoughts rooted in greed, hatred and delusion lead to disharmony
and suffering
-
thoughts rooted in generosity, loving-friendliness, compassion
and wisdom lead to harmony and peace
-
As the mind begins to understand suffering and its cause
(craving), it begins to lose interest in its attachment to sensual stimuli,
rests in each moment with equanimity, and responds appropriately to each
moment as wisdom naturally arises.
-
Skillful Thinking is Intentions of:
-
Generosity - Letting Go (Renunciation): Material, People,
Experiences and Beliefs
-
Loving-Friendliness or Metta (Goodwill): wishing for the
happiness and welfare of others
-
Compassion (Harmlessness) - understanding the suffering of
others and wishing them to be free from suffering
-
Then we explored Virtue: Skillful Speech, Skillful Action
and Skillful Livelihood and saw the application of Skillful Understanding
and Skillful Thinking in our daily lives: seeing the causal connection
between --
-
skillful intentions and actions and resulting harmony
and peacefulness in our minds and in our lives
-
unskillful intentions and actions and resulting
disharmony
and disruption in our minds and in our lives
-
We will conclude Skillful Action and Skillful Livelihood
today and begin to examine the third section of the Path, Concentration,
as we experience Skillful Effort, Skillful Mindfulness & Skillful Concentration.
-
Sharing of Experiences (have class help me illustrate Skillful
Action and Skillful Livelihood in their own experiences).
-
Keeping in mind Skillful Understanding (Law of Cause
and Effect -- The Truth of Suffering and its Cause: Craving) and
Skillful
Thinking (Generosity or Letting Go, Loving-Friendliness, and Compassion
or Harmlessness), and their application in Skillful Speech,
Skillful
Action and Skillful Livelihood, let us now consider the appropriate
amount
of exertion in our practice and its skillful application by
considering Skillful Effort
-
There are six senses: seeing, hearing, touching, tasting,
smelling, and thinking. The last of these senses gives us the most trouble:
thinking. The mind seems to have "a mind of its own".
EXAMPLES FROM THE CLASS?
-
Unwholesome thoughts trigger feelings, which may be pleasant,
unpleasant or neutral. Unless one is mindful, attending to such feelings
with wise attention, the the mind will naturally react in habitual ways,
often by piling on additional unwholesome thoughts which intensify the
feelings and the minds reaction to such feelings with unskillful speech
or action.
-
What are unwholesome thoughts? They are states of
mind that block us from experiencing happiness. No matter how they manifest,
they have the same basic roots: greed, hatred and delusion.
-
The Buddha described ten deep, powerful psychic irritants
called "the fetters". The presence of fetters cause each lifetime and its
suffering, prevents enlightenment, and guarantees future lives. They are,
in the order in which they must be overcome on the way to enlightenment:
-
Fetters overcome at the first stage of enlightenment --
-
belief in the existence of a permanent self or soul
-
doubt in the message of the Buddha
-
belief that one can end suffering merely by following rules
and rituals
-
Fetters overcome to reach the second and third stages --
-
greed for sensual pleasures (gross greed)
-
hatred
-
Fetters overcome to reach the final stage --
-
subtle desire to exist in a fine material form
-
subtle desire to exist in immaterial form
-
conceit, or the underlying perception of self-identity
-
restlessness and worry
-
ignorance
-
Out of the Ten Fetters comes certain crude, extremely unwholesome
mind states that prevent one from making progress in one's meditation --
The Five Hindrances:
-
Greed - the desire to obtain pleasurable things
-
Ill Will - hatred, anger, resentment, irritation
-
Dullness and Drowsiness
-
Restlessness and Worry
-
Doubt
-
Now that we know what unwholesome mind states are, how can
we
recognize them?
-
We recognize an unwholesome thought by the feeling
that precedes it -- if one notes a sense of obscurity, heaviness, sadness,
unhappiness, or discontent, an unwholesome thought will follow, with a
whole series of negative effects in its wake.
-
Recall the intention that preceded that thought stream
-- was it rooted in greed, hatred or delusion? (unwholesome) Or was it
rooted in generosity, loving-friendliness, or compassion? (wholesome)
-
How does one guard and protect oneself from the onslaught
of unwholesome thoughts? The Buddha prescribed "the four great efforts"
(Saccavibhanga Sutta):
-
When unwholesome thoughts have not yet arisen, do not let
them arise.
-
When unwholesome thoughts have already arisen, do not let
them go any further and abandon them.
-
Let wholesome thoughts that have not yet arisen arise.
-
Take wholesome thoughts that have already arisen and cultivate
them so that they will be carried further.
-
In another sutta (Anguttara Nikaya, Book of the Twos, #10),
the Buddha gave these instructions:
"Abandon what is unskillful. One
can abandon the unskillful. If it were not possible, I would not ask
you to do it. If this abandoning of the unskillful would bring harm
and suffering, I would not ask you to abandon it. But as it brings benefit
and happiness, therefore I say, abandon what is unskillful."
"Cultivate the good. One can cultivate
the good. If it were not possible, I would not ask you to do it.
If this cultivation were to bring harm and suffering, I would not ask you
to do it. But as this cultivation brings joy and happiness, I say
cultivate the good."(i.e., skillful)
See also, Samanamandika
Sutta (MN 78) and sutta
notes by Mike Potter
-
That's fine as far as it goes, but how does one abandon
unwholesome thoughts and cultivate wholesome thoughts?
-
Be very careful here -- we can end up with a lot of grasping
and a lot of aversion:
-
Get rid of the unwholesome mind states?
-
Grab hold of and cling to the wholesome mind states?
-
We're back to dukkha again
-
Abandon doesn't mean get behind it and boot it out. It means,
let go of.
-
But how do we let go of the unskillful?
-
We must trust in our own Buddha nature - our
innate goodness.
-
We're not like a potter shaping a bowl out of raw material
which resists our shaping and fights to remain raw earth, so much as like
someone who holds a very perfect bowl, encrusted with mud and debris. We
gently wash it off, inviting it to bring forth its already present
true being.
-
So I like to think of this effort of "inviting" rather than
"forcing". There's patience there, and trust.
-
We can find the answer within our practice.
It's a simple
question of what works.
-
If I'm filled with anger and make a decision, "I'll abandon
anger; I won't experience anger," of course that doesn't work.
-
Where does the anger go? It's still there; I've just buried
it. It leaks out everywhere.
-
To truly abandon anger, one must get to know anger; this
is both with the wisdom mind which sees the nature of anger as of
all conditioned experience as holding the three characteristics, and with
the heart, the compassionate heart which watches fear and pain nonjudgmentally;
then we really know how anger develops, know that whatever has the
nature to arise has the nature to cease and is not me or mine.
-
Yet we still laugh and weep, and see that unwholesome mind
states still do arise.
-
But we stop the identification with them. Anger is
just anger. When the conditions which support it cease, it will cease.
-
We wrongly put attention on the result,
trying to fix
it, rather than employing mindfulness, growing wisdom and compassion
to attend to the conditions, no longer caught in the result.
-
The same can be said of greed: don't shut it out, but don't
indulge in it either. -- it will just sweep your attention away in a current
of "wanting" -- more, and more, and more -- its insatiable.
-
To truly abandon greed, one must get to know it.
-
Then, when it arises, one attends to it with mindfulness,
wisdom and compassion, no longer caught in the result.
-
And how does one cultivate the good? By applying mindfulness
and developing skillful responses rooted in generosity, loving-kindness,
compassion and wisdom.
-
In Right Effort there is ease, receptivity, energy, presence,
willing invitation, but not grasping. Be kind to yourself.
-
When a contraction arises -- be it mental or physical --
invite it in, get to know it directly, with kindness and gratitude.
-
If fear arises, just note it. See that it arises due to causes
and conditions. Always from a sense of self.
-
When fear can be observed as a conditioned phenomenon, it
loses its power -- for it is not being fed with aversion.
-
When its not fed, it dies a natural death.
-
Right Effort is just to notice the movement; loving intention
offers spaciousness.
-
Gradually, these skillful responses will become tendencies;
and tendencies will become habit; and habit will become character -- so
that we can respond skillfully in everyday situations, bringing joy and
happiness to our lives, and to the lives of others.
-
So what does Skillful Effort feel like?
The Rock Exercise:
-
Put the rock in the palm of your hand.
-
Grasp it as tightly as you can. (This is the effort that
people often bring to their practice.)
-
Explore the physical sensations in your body - pain, discomfort,
tension.
-
Then open your hand.
-
Notice the rock - its not crushed; it hasn't gone away.
-
Notice that it is gently resting in your palm; just being
held gently. Notice the touch sensation: the hardness, the lightness or
heaviness; the differences in the touch sensation at various touch points
-- sharp or smooth edges. Notice its temperature.
-
These are it's true characteristics. It is only the earth
element (hardness); the water element (cohesion); and the fire element
(temperature) and air (motion and pressure due to gravity)-- nothing more.
-
This is what it brings to you. You need not add anything
to it.
-
Open, spacious, tensionless effort . . .
-
A non-doing effort . . . this is Skillful Effort
-
Assignment for next week:
-
Homework
Schedule (Review Exercises)
-
Review Eight Mindful Steps to Happiness - Step 6: Skillful
Effort
-
Read Eight Mindful Steps to Happiness - Step 7: Skillful
Mindfulness
-
Closing Meditation